Skip to content

Download E-books Ancient Readings of Plato S "Phaedo" (Philosophia Antiqua) PDF

Plato s "Phaedo" hasn't ever did not allure the eye of philosophers and students. but the historical past of its reception in Antiquity has been little studied. the current quantity for that reason proposes to envision not just the Platonic exegetical culture surrounding this discussion, which culminates within the commentaries of Damascius and Olympiodorus, but in addition its position within the reflections of the rival Peripatetic, Stoic, and Sceptical faculties. This quantity hence goals to make clear the surviving commentaries and their resources, in addition to on much less prevalent facets of the historical past of the "Phaedo" s historical reception. by means of doing so, it will probably support to explain what old interpreters of Plato can and can't provide their modern counterparts."

Show description

Read Online or Download Ancient Readings of Plato S "Phaedo" (Philosophia Antiqua) PDF

Best Philosophy books

Theatetus (Penguin Classics)

Set instantly sooner than the trial and execution of Socrates in 399 BC, Theaetetus indicates the nice thinker contemplating the character of data itself, in a debate with the geometrician Theodorus and his younger follower Theaetetus. Their discussion covers many questions, akin to: is wisdom merely subjective, composed of the ever-changing move of impressions we obtain from the surface international?

In Defense of Sentimentality (Passionate Life)

Philosophy has as a lot to do with emotions because it does with recommendations and considering. Philosophy, as a result, calls for not just emotional sensitivity yet an figuring out of the feelings, no longer as curious yet marginal mental phenomena yet because the very substance of existence. during this, the second one booklet in a chain dedicated to his paintings at the feelings, Robert Solomon offers a security of the sentiments and of sentimentality opposed to the historical past of what he perceives as an extended historical past of abuse in philosophy and social concept and artwork and literary feedback.

From Empedocles to Wittgenstein: Historical Essays in Philosophy

From Empedocles to Wittgenstein is a suite of fifteen historic essays in philosophy, written through Sir Anthony Kenny within the early years of the twenty first century. often they're occupied with 4 of the nice philosophers whom he such a lot esteems, specifically Plato, Aristotle, Aquinas, and Wittgenstein.

The Philosopher's Plant: An Intellectual Herbarium

Regardless of their conceptual hypersensitivity to vegetal existence, philosophers have used germination, progress, blossoming, fruition, copy, and rot as illustrations of summary options; pointed out crops in passing because the common backdrops for dialogues, letters, and different compositions; spun tricky allegories out of vegetation, timber, or even grass; and suggested applicable medicinal, nutritional, and aesthetic ways to pick species of vegetation.

Extra resources for Ancient Readings of Plato S "Phaedo" (Philosophia Antiqua)

Show sample text content

Desclos—W. W. Fortenbaugh (eds. ), Strato of Lampsacus. textual content, Translation and dialogue, New Brunswick—London: Transaction Books, 2011, 5–229. 2 Sharples (‘Strato of Lampsacus’, 10–12, following Gottschalk) declared Wehrli’s version specifically unsuitable on those texts. © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, 2015 | doi: 10. 1163/9789004289543_004 38 baltussen Damascius’ remark at the Phaedo. three it's usually simply because those authors appear ignorant of each one other’s interpretive efforts and since they don't seem to be in complete contract nor hide all facets that I suggest to topic those most modern remedies of Strato to a short comparative assessment. I shall exhibit that one paper has weaknesses, and that the opposite will be considered as complementary to my very own analyzing. My proposed examining will contain a few polemic with the intention to achieving a brand new inclusive studying of Strato, yet also will objective to figure out extra thoroughly the measure to which we might name Strato’s puzzles ‘dialectical’ via clarifying the character of those objections and their functionality in Damascius. 1 the matter: Fragmentary innovations To unmarried out the aporiai of the 3rd head of the Peripatos on Plato’s Phaedo preserved in ‘fragments’ embedded within the paintings of a past due old Platonist thinker turns out before everything look a unsafe venture. As Westerink has made transparent, the textual content is sort of complicated because of its transmission and the a number of palms excited about its composition, together with apo phônês notes through a pupil in models. four you can supply numerous purposes, then, for why it truly is unsafe to unmarried out elements of the sort of layered textual content: we have now little greater than fragments ultimate of the early Peripatetics after Aristotle, that is through definition a disadvantage to their interpretation. What we do have for Strato at the Phaedo doesn't appear like a really coherent interpretation in any respect: it's a choice of ‘objections’—‘puzzles’ (ἀπορίαι)—in a kind and association that can now not be absolutely his personal. basically their unique context is misplaced. five we can't also be yes three D. Modrak, ‘Physicalism in Strato’s Psychology’, in: Desclos—Fortenbaugh, Strato of Lampsacus, 383–397; L. Repici, ‘Strato’s Aporiai on Plato’s Phaedo’, in: Desclos—Fortenbaugh, Strato of Lampsacus, 423–442; S. Gertz, dying and Immortality in past due Neoplatonism. reports at the historic Commentators on Plato’s Phaedo, Leiden: Brill, 2011. four Westerink even thought of the remedy by way of Damascius a separate paintings, calling it ‘the Monograph at the Argument from Opposites within the Phaedo (i §207–252)’ (The Greek Commentators on Plato’s Phaedo. Vol. ii: Damascius, ed. and tr. by way of L. G. Westerink, Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1977, 10). five Gottschalk already said this challenge (Strato of Lampsacus: a few Texts, ed. with a comm. via H. B. Gottschalk, Leeds: court cases of the Leeds Philosophical and Literary Society, vol. xi, half vi, one hundred sixty five; my italics): ‘Proclus in different places prices Strato’s περὶ τοῦ ὄντος (= Str. 40–41 sa), and it is only attainable that this can be the paintings from which those arguments have been taken. however the probably resource (if they stood in a single of Strato’s released works in any respect) is the περὶ φύσεως ἀνθρωπίνης.

Rated 4.04 of 5 – based on 49 votes