By David T. Johnson
Prosecutors have extra regulate over existence, liberty, and popularity than any association in Japan. paradoxically, this proposition elicits frequent contract yet few severe efforts to discover its factors, results, or importance. The irony makes the procuracy a bit just like the climate: every body discusses it yet nobody does whatever approximately it.
This is the 1st booklet in English to research how Japan's 2000 prosecutors workout their bold powers. It paints an empirical comic strip of prosecutors at paintings, the contexts during which they examine, cost, and check out circumstances, and the content material of the selections thereby rendered. considering the fact that prosecutors wield colossal discretion at each degree of the felony technique, and because felony complaints represent one of many central signs of the nature of a society, this research bargains a window onto Japan. in view that this e-book is comparative, mainly with the U.S., it additionally provides insights into American legislations and society.
The eastern means of justice is largely made up our minds incidentally prosecutors practice their jobs. If justice capacity making an allowance for the wishes and conditions of person suspects, then prosecutors in Japan needs to obtain better marks than their American opposite numbers. If justice implies treating like circumstances alike, then the capability of Japan's procuracy to take action is outstanding certainly. If justice should still advertise therapeutic, not only punishment, then eastern prosecutors needs to be reckoned extra restorative than prosecutors within the usa. And if justice depends upon uncovering and clarifying the reality, then readers will realize how basic this maxim is deemed in Japan. In those methods and extra, the japanese method of justice is uncommonly simply.
Yet this account uncovers severe defects in addition. In processing intercourse offenders, for instance, jap prosecutors commonly and disrespect the emotions of lady sufferers. of their ardour for retaining excessive conviction premiums, prosecutors sacrifice the pursuits of sufferers who yearn to be heard in open court docket. of their insulation from political and public scrutiny, prosecutors occasionally appear unaccountable to valid authority and impact. And of their zeal to acquire the reality via confessions, a few prosecutors plea cut price, health practitioner file, and behavior brutal interrogations, all of that are unlawful in Japan.
Japan is some distance from the USA. This ebook demonstrates that during many issues of legal justice they're diversified worlds.
Read or Download The Japanese Way of Justice: Prosecuting Crime in Japan (Studies on Law and Social Control) PDF
Similar Japan books
Winner of the Pulitzer PrizeIn this groundbreaking biography of the japanese emperor Hirohito, Herbert P. Bix bargains the 1st entire, unvarnished examine the enigmatic chief whose sixty-three-year reign ushered Japan into the fashionable global. by no means sooner than has the whole lifetime of this arguable determine been published with such readability and vividness.
Japan is arguably present day such a lot winning business financial system, combining virtually exceptional affluence with social balance and obvious concord. eastern items and cultural products--from lively video clips and machine video games to vehicles, semiconductors, and administration techniques--are fed on all over the world.
A contemporary historical past of Japan: From Tokugawa occasions to the current, 3rd version, paints a richly nuanced and strikingly unique portrait of the final centuries of jap background. It takes scholars from the times of the shogunate--the feudal overlordship of the Tokugawa family--through the modernizing revolution introduced by means of midlevel samurai within the past due 19th century; the adoption of Western hairstyles, garments, and army association; and the nation's first experiments with mass democracy after global warfare I.
From the past due 19th century, Japan sought to include the Korean Peninsula into its increasing empire. Japan took regulate of Korea in 1910 and governed it until eventually the top of global conflict II. in this colonial interval, Japan marketed as a countrywide objective the assimilation of Koreans into the japanese country.
Additional resources for The Japanese Way of Justice: Prosecuting Crime in Japan (Studies on Law and Social Control)
The defendant needs to consent to take advantage of of this approach. The precis courtroom examines basically documentary and actual facts submitted by means of the prosecutor and will impose at the defendant a ﬁne no longer exceeding 500,000 yen ($4,167). 10 greater than ninety percentage of all circumstances are disposed of during this method. critical situations are officially prosecuted after which attempted in District or precis courtroom. The one-phase trial. an ordeal court docket which includes one or 3 judges announces guilt or innocence and imposes sentence within the comparable continuing; the decision and sentence should not bifurcated, as within the usa. other than in Okinawa, Japan has had no jury trials in view that 1943. Trials convene discontinuously at a velocity of approximately one consultation monthly. the typical 10. until another way indicated, this e-book makes use of an alternate cost of $1 ϭ one hundred twenty yen. advent 15 trial takes a bit greater than 3 months to ﬁnish, and ninety four percentage of trials ﬁnish in six months or much less. Trials are meant to be antagonistic. In perform, in spite of the fact that, over ninety percentage of defendants confess, and courts count seriously on documentary facts (dossiers) that prosecutors have submitted. Prosecutors can charm any ﬁrst-instance court docket choice, together with acquittals. In sum, prosecutors in Japan practice 4 significant roles that American prosecutors both don't play in any other case practice in a markedly attenuated demeanour (Uviller 2000). First, jap prosecutors behavior pre-charge investigations and interrogations, either all alone initiative and at the side of the police. by means of comparability, American prosecutors seldom examine or interrogate, other than on the Federal point. moment, jap prosecutors have monopoly energy to get rid of situations via making cost judgements, and should decide to drop any cost, regardless of how critical the case or powerful the facts. by contrast, American prosecutors proportion the cost selection with different actors, together with police (in rural jurisdictions especially), judges (in initial hearings), grand juries, and, albeit hardly ever, electorate (in“private prosecutions”). 3rd, jap prosecutors current the state’s case at trial, suggest a formal judgment to the court docket, and charm acquittals and sentencing judgements. by contrast, American prosecutors can't allure acquittals and will attraction sentences simply in restricted jurisdictions and limited situations. eventually, eastern prosecutors supervise the execution of sentences, making sure that ﬁnes are paid and that correctional ofﬁcials perform all different punishments—including demise sentences—imposed by means of the court docket. American prosecutors have few parallel powers to oversee the execution of sentences. The scope of prosecutorial authority is big in Japan. The proof offered hereafter means that prosecutors use their strength, for the main half, to generate justice of a high quality that merits extra appreciate (and study awareness) than it hitherto has bought. an outline of the publication This ebook unfolds in installments. half I, “The Contexts of jap Justice,” assumes close-up of prosecutors is much less instructive than a caricature that areas them in broader standpoint.